When Christmas Comes Again by Beth Seid El Levine
Come across a Problem?
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Friend Reviews
Community Reviews
There actually is no mention of the real meaning of Christmas. There is one mention of Simone hoping an angel ornamentation will protect her brother and friend in the fighting. ...more
her parents give her per this volume is almost the life of Simone Spencer during World State of war 1. in the story Simone leads an boilerplate life equally a student, who sometimes helps the YMCA. just a few days after her graduation, her blood brother is leaving to go to state of war. during the year that her brother, Will, is gone life seems awfully boring for Simone, until she comes up with a vivid idea. when she is 17, Simone asks her parents if she can help in the state of war by working on the phone lines almost the battlefront.
her parents give her permission and she is shipped to Paris in a few days. Simone spends time exploring Paris and with other girls. she presently becomes friends with a girl named Alice, who's by Simone'south side a lot of the time. they(forth with some other girls work on the telephone lines many hours a 24-hour interval. their jobs are important because urgent messages are sent and are to be sent by all the girls.
the girls are constantly moving from identify to place and are always getting closer to the battlefront. there is a dance on one nighttime and Simone finds her blood brother Will and her true beloved. she and a boy named Sam Cates meet each other in dances and they autumn in love. unfortunately, Sam is being sent to the adjacent day, along with Sam and the other soldiers.
during the wintertime of 1918, the girls face harsh conditions and take difficulty in their jobs. Alice gets sick day by day, for it turns out that she has a affliction! Alice's death wish is for Simone to write her family a letter most how she cares about them. Simone fulfills her wish and mails it to Alice's family unit.
after many rough battles against the Germans, America finally wins the state of war! Simone and Volition are finally returning home, and just in time to gloat Christmas.but, it turns out that Volition saw the death of Sam. Simone doesn't lose hope, though considering she is certain that Sam did survive. as everyone is reunited during Christmas Eve, Simone goes to aid in the hospital and is taken by surprise when she finds Sam on a hospital bed.
although Sam is alive, he isn't unharmed. it turns out that a grenade blew part of his leg off. unfortunately, Sam volition have to stay in the infirmary for rehabilitation. Male parent all the same, manages to bring Sam to their dwelling house to celebrate Christmas with them. all ends very well in Simone's life, only i can't tell yous everything, and then read the Epilogue to observe out. ...more
If that seems overly simplistic for a WWI story, You'D BE RIGHT.
I think the hard truth is that I have just outgrown these books. I take plenty base knowledge that these books no longer spark that interest; they don't whet my appetite; they experience similar they're nether-delivering on ver
Simone Spencer, aged 17, volunteers with the Point Corps to go to France and serve as a switchboard operator at the front lines. While overseas, she makes a friend, discovers the depths of grief, and falls in love.If that seems overly simplistic for a WWI story, YOU'D BE Correct.
I call up the hard truth is that I have just outgrown these books. I have enough base knowledge that these books no longer spark that interest; they don't whet my appetite; they feel similar they're under-delivering on very serious, complex topics. I want to sink my teeth into them but there'due south nothing there: it's like a mouthful of cotton wool candy, melting down into a stomach ache.
...more
There's a lot that Simone's story has going for it - musings on class relations and recognizing one's privilege as a member of the upper cl
"The thing is, if in your life, you never got whatever bad news, never got weary, never got the wind knocked out of you lot, well, there would be nothing left in this world to move you. And there would be no reason at all to well upwards in a teary grin and concur on tight to everything y'all love. I know now that that's the whole signal. That'southward the whole point of everything."There'due south a lot that Simone's story has going for it - musings on course relations and recognizing one'due south privilege as a member of the upper class, the struggle to preserve some sort of teenage girlhood while in a foreign country at war, and the complicated mix of emotions in bliss at the war being over and the grim realization that both she and her earth will never quite be the same.
For those who argue that Simone has no label and that her diary entries are lackluster, I disagree completely. She clashes with her grandmother and other "high order" women over their expectations of her. She isn't as radical equally her suffragist friend Francie, but Simone develops an agreement of women's empowerment through her experience as a "howdy daughter" switchboard operator. I related strongly to her anxieties over graduating loftier school and wanting to make a difference in the world without knowing what that deviation could be.
Equally far equally the diary entries go, earlier the war she couldn't observe the motivation to write and afterward the war she couldn't observe the time. She writes sporadically when she can, jotting down a few words in earlier she sleeps. She's working twelve hour shifts - she doesn't accept fourth dimension or energy to hammer out a dissertation every night. It's not realistic, especially when her days consist of the same monotonous and stress-inducing switchboards over and over again.
For those who criticize her love story with Sam and how quickly information technology progresses, I again take to disagree. She grew up hearing all almost how her mother and male parent roughshod in love at start sight, so it's merely natural that she would desire to find that same kind of heart-stopping honey for herself. The traumas that she and Sam experienced at state of war bind them together as much every bit sharing a dance, and in an unfamiliar world where you lot don't know if you are going to survive to see the adjacent mean solar day or not, you don't always have the luxury to take the time to fall in honey. Simone utilized her love for Sam (as well every bit her brother) as a mode to motivate herself and keep her focused on the importance of her work.
I finished the book in one sitting with tears in my eyes. Is the ending a lilliputian also saccharine? Perhaps. Does that actually matter? In that location are likewise many DA books with gross mischaracterizations of their subject matter for me to be bothered that Simone'due south biggest flaw is she gets a happy ending. /endrant
...more
2018 Review:
This book is part of
2018 Review:
This volume is office of the Honey America series, a middle grade historical fiction serial near and dear to my centre. I hope to review many Dear Americas in the future, but I'k excited that my first one happens to be one of my all-fourth dimension favorites!
When Christmas Comes Once more by Beth Seidel Levine is ane of the few (if not the but) Dear America about a seventeen-twelvemonth-old girl. Most of the Beloved America heroines are betwixt twelve and fourteen years old, and so you can imagine my excitement when I was finally the exact same historic period equally the main character. Therefore, Simone'due south questions about her time to come and her meaning in life are very relatable as I asked myself like questions at that historic period. Also, Simone's family is French and as I am French-Canadian, I loved the bits of French language and references throughout the diary.
I'll acknowledge I might be a niggling biased equally Earth War I is my favorite time period and this book happens to take place so, only ultimately, a good story is a good story. Simone, in wanting to make a difference, ends up signing on for a job that is more than she bargained for. Existence a Hi Daughter is not easy, but involves high-stress situations where her communications with Centrolineal soldiers not only have to be coded, only she must help them reach their goals in calling, if she can. Simone wonders if she's strong enough, but she doesn't take fourth dimension to determine whether she is or not because they need her—now. Sometimes it's not about having strength before a situation arises, but getting through the situation which then gives you strength. This story is rich in history and I loved learning well-nigh another side of World War I we don't often hear well-nigh.
At that place is romance, there is friendship, there is loneliness and there is heartache. Life lived during a war—any war—is often cruel and unfair. And questions are often left unanswered. But Simone pushes through it and when she returns abode, she is fabricated dissimilar past her experiences. She can never return to the sweet, innocent New York gal she once was, but she would never go back. Ane of my favorite quotes from the book perfectly reflects this thought:
"The thing is, if in your life, yous never got any bad news, never got weary, never got the wind knocked out of y'all, well, there would be zippo left in this world to move y'all. And there would be no reason at all to well up in a teary grinning and hold on tight to everything you love. I know now that that's the whole point. That's the whole point to everything."
If that didn't just give you chills, there's zippo more I tin do.
I give When Christmas Comes Over again 5 out of 5 stars. It's geared toward middle form readers, simply just as entertaining and educational for high schoolers and across. While the story does not entirely heart around Christmas time, it begins and ends with Christmas. Considering Christmas marks a time for families to be together—happy, content and at peace. There was no peace for the Spencer family unit in 1917 and although Earth War I had changed them greatly, they had peace in Christmas of 1918. This demonstrates that while we may not have peace now, we can await forward to the peace to come up.
...more than
Wanting to help in some way, Simone searches for options, volunteering at the YMCA for some time, and even looking into being a nurse for the Ruby-Cantankerous. Merely after seeing the men at the hospital in crit
With the war swiftly approaching, seventeen year quondam Simone Spencer's older brother, Volition, immediately registers before a draft comes. Equally the state of war progresses, Simone begins to feel helpless, and her own New York City remains as it e'er was, then it's easy to forget that there's a war going on at all.Wanting to help in some way, Simone searches for options, volunteering at the YMCA for some time, and even looking into beingness a nurse for the Ruddy-Cross. Just later seeing the men at the infirmary in critical condition, Simone doubts that being a nurse is the right pick.
When Full general John J. Pershing calls for young women to join his ranks to operate switchboards, Simone is thrilled, and when the ages are lowered, she immediately starts training. That'due south when the real action begins.
This book weaved humor, anger, happiness, and sorrow so well. Simone's own perspective, her losses, her fury, her happiness, her sadness, they were written beautifully. I have a bright imagination, and the words brought it to life.
Though the catastrophe was bittersweet, equally told, even Simone didn't wish anything differently. If her grief, if sad things had non happened, if her life had not e'er been sorrow filled, so in the terminate, she wouldn't exist able to exist truly appreciate the joy that came in the stop.
...more
3/five on here, 6/ten for myself.
Okay, so the catastrophe was a footling sappy and contrived, merely that'due south fine. The rest of the book...well, information technology's interesting, but mostly considering I didn't realize women went over to Europe during WWI in any other capacity than "nurse." So that office was cool. Yet, the book itself was just kinda...meh. It didn't seem terribly well-written or anything. In other words, topic = interesting, book = non so much.iii/5 on here, vi/10 for myself.
...more
I actually enjoyed returning to this lovely Dear America story, which was the start one I ever read! It endures as one of my all-time favorites. Great characters, strong historical setting, charming romance, expert lessons, and an catastrophe that's tied up as pretty as a Christmas bow—what more could yous enquire for during the holidays?!
[2021 Review]I really enjoyed returning to this lovely Dear America story, which was the beginning 1 I always read! It endures every bit 1 of my all-time favorites. Groovy characters, strong historical setting, charming romance, adept lessons, and an ending that's tied upwardly as pretty equally a Christmas bow—what more could you lot inquire for during the holidays?!
...more
This book likewise gives adept descriptions of Simone'south interest in the war without beingness as well graphic for younger readers. I would say that this book could take moved a little faster in the beginning, considering to me it seemed a little dull until Simone went overseas. This book had several proficient quotes that gave me things to consider that I had not thought of before.
I really enjoyed this book, information technology gave a girl's perspective of being in World War I, which is non really a common occurrence. I as well recollect it gave enough details yet was vague enough that even upper elementary students can enjoy and learn from the book.
I would recommend this volume for students to read independently for 5th or sixth grade. To use this book for a read aloud, I would recommend quaternary or fifth grades.
...more than
This is a PG romance masquerading as a Dear America book. At that place, I said it!
At present don't become me wrong, it wasn't terrible, simply I felt this was a 50/l divide between a honey story and a historical fiction. Everything was very...fairytale happy. Simone instantly knows that Sam is the love of her life. She never doubts whether he's dead or alive. They get married and live happily ever after. Even the friend she makes in hospital ends up being part of her happy always afterward thanks to
Unpopular stance time!This is a PG romance masquerading as a Dear America book. In that location, I said information technology!
Now don't get me incorrect, information technology wasn't terrible, simply I felt this was a fifty/50 split betwixt a love story and a historical fiction. Everything was very...fairytale happy. Simone instantly knows that Sam is the love of her life. She never doubts whether he'due south dead or live. They become married and live happily always later. Even the friend she makes in hospital ends upward existence part of her happy always after thank you to her best friend. Her fourth dimension as a switchboard operator was...okay. It doesn't go into likewise much detail and she skips a lot of time because she'due south so "decorated."
All in all it was okay. Not the greatest merely non terrible by whatsoever ways.
Actual rating 2.5 stars out of five.
...more
I'll be honest that I don't actually think learning much about WWI in schoolhouse, then much of the content was new to me. I've only briefly heard of Hi Girls before this.
This one definitely rugged at my heartstrings and Simone was such a badass graphic symbol. I loved the strong girl ability theme here.
My only bodily complaint was the slightly misleading title. Nearly of the volume didn't have
Probably one of my favorite Dear America books! I don't think this is one I read equally a child, so it was all new to me.I'll be honest that I don't really recall learning much about WWI in school, then much of the content was new to me. I've but briefly heard of Hello Girls before this.
This one definitely rugged at my heartstrings and Simone was such a badass graphic symbol. I loved the stiff girl ability theme hither.
My just actual complaint was the slightly misleading championship. Most of the volume didn't have place effectually Christmas. But information technology did pb back to the hope that the whole family would exist together once again come Christmas.
...more
This is a squeamish intro to New York City and WWI during 1917-1918. The "Hello Girls" of the US Army Signal Corps are petty known or remembered ladies who served their country with distinction during this "modern war". These were basis-breaking women. This is a quick, enjoyable read.
Naomi brought three Dear America titles home from the library - once again. She has her favorites that she revisits a couple times a year.This is a nice intro to New York City and WWI during 1917-1918. The "Hello Girls" of the The states Army Signal Corps are piffling known or remembered ladies who served their country with distinction during this "modern war". These were basis-breaking women. This is a quick, enjoyable read.
...more
Related Articles
Welcome back. Simply a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/875653.When_Christmas_Comes_Again
0 Response to "When Christmas Comes Again by Beth Seid El Levine"
Post a Comment